Hacker News

Favorites Setup
Comment by mapontosevenths | original | All AI-generated code should be Open Source
[−]mapontosevenths · 2026-11-15 Sun 16:31 UTC · link
I wonder if the defendant knew about https://allthemusic.info/?

There are only so many ways to express notes, and they've essentially all been done.

[−]VBprogrammer · 2026-11-15 Sun 16:46 UTC · link
These kinds of goofy technocratic work arounds rarely sway legal procedures.
[−]odo1242 · 2026-11-15 Sun 16:49 UTC · link
It’s not necessarily a technocratic workaround, the point is that every song sounds like something if you look hard enough, so the bar for copyright violation should be higher.
[−]SOLAR_FIELDS · 2026-11-15 Sun 17:02 UTC · link
It is a mathematical truth that there is a finite amount of first 8 bars of music combinations melody wise, so it's a worthwhile discussion to bring up whether it should even be possible to copyright them.
[−]VBprogrammer · 2026-11-15 Sun 18:07 UTC · link
The mathematics of that would have been well understood in Bach's day. Does generating all of them make much difference? I don't really think so.

I'm not arguing the copyright situation isn't wrong. Just that generating them isn't likely to sway anything in the legal world.

[−]rcxdude · 2026-11-15 Sun 18:01 UTC · link
They might help highlight the absurdity of some of the precedents set when the amount of commercial music was much lower than today, though.
[−]matkoniecz · 2026-11-15 Sun 18:07 UTC · link
I can also trivially write program enumerating over all possible text arrangements, so what?
[−]Animats · 2026-11-15 Sun 18:32 UTC · link
Has anyone matched large volumes of existing music to that? How many of the 12-note combinations have been used more than once? Most of that space sounds awful, and it's likely that human compositions are all in a small portion of the possible 12 note combinations.