Hacker News

Favorites Setup
Comment by shevy-java | original | Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case
[−]shevy-java · 2026-11-15 Sun 09:17 UTC · link
It's good that the courts finally look at the price fixing of the RAM cartel. I think it must become a much bigger lawsuit. It can not be that these de-facto monopolies keep on fixing the prices upwards. Even in a very capitalistic society such as the USA was once (before the orange mafia hijacked the country, even though in a more recent election the mafia lost big), capitalism assumes that free market competition lowers the prices and affordability for the average Joe, as a buyer. Clearly this is NOT the case here in the RAM cartel. You now pay like 3x as much as you did two or three years ago - and the high prices are maintained. That's a cartel. That has nothing to do with a free market.

I also think mandatory jail times for the CEOs need to happen. It can not be that they can buy their way out of punishments and damage they cause against society.

[−]toyg · 2026-11-15 Sun 09:40 UTC · link
Capitalism does not assume anything. If anything, unfettered capitalism naturally gravitate towards monopolies and rent-seeking, since they provide large and stable margins. The technological progress is an accidental byproduct of efficiency drives, which is an occasional byproduct of economic systems in specific historical circumstances.
[−]Jensson · 2026-11-15 Sun 12:29 UTC · link
Capitalism assume that the government uses force to enforce contracts. Without that capital accumulates with those that have military power instead of those that invests, which is much worse.
[−]OroPla · 2026-11-15 Sun 11:22 UTC · link
> capitalism assumes that free market competition lowers the prices and affordability for the average Joe

Capitalism is defined by:

- the means of production (factories, tools, employees, land,..)

- being owned privately (as opposed to being state owned)

- for profit (so you do not have to live paycheck to paycheck)

A free market is defined by:

- price of goods is set by supply and demand

- the government doesn't intervene (for example through subsidies)

Price fixing is defined by:

- all the sellers (or buyers) agreeing on and therefore setting the price

- price is not set by supply and demand, therefore you do not have a free market

[−]sophrosyne42 · 2026-11-15 Sun 17:00 UTC · link
in a world where production facilities take multiple years to create, but demand increases a ton in less than that time, I would expect high prices for multiple years, with or without monopoly. The existence of a higher price than in the past is simply not evidence of a monopoly nor something going wrong.