Hacker News

Favorites Setup
Comment by ButlerianJihad | original | Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope
[−]ButlerianJihad · 2026-08-29 Sat 17:08 UTC · link
It is not 500mbps but 500Mbps. https://science.nasa.gov/mission/roman-space-telescope/commu...

"mbps" is a meaningless abbreviation. You need to consistently and correctly use capital letters when communicating technical terms. You cannot "e e cummings" your way into effective writing.

500 megabits per second works out to 5.4 terabytes per day. No idea where you get 1.5, unless you were thinking of 500Mb/hour!

60 × 60 × 24 × 500 × 1000000 ÷ 8

[−]ck2 · 2026-08-29 Sat 17:47 UTC · link
my brain is not what it used to be due to long-covid so it's very possible I made a mistake

but 500 megabits per second to me is 500mbps?

ie. my cablemodem is 100mbps which is 100 megabits per second?

and that would [make Roman] 5.4 Terrabytes aka 5.4TB per day

but the transmitter is not at full speed full power 24/7

so it is 1.5TB per day in documentation that I do not have handy but vaguely remember

to repeat the more amazing part is that is from a MILLION MILES away, wow

(JWST "only" does 23mbps, 23 megabits per second)

[−]Sharlin · 2026-08-29 Sat 18:14 UTC · link
The GP is alluding to the fact that the prefix "m" means milli-, not mega-. But that's pointless pedantry. Nobody would ever think that you meant 0.5 bits per second, and bit isn't a SI unit anyway.
[−]ButlerianJihad · 2026-08-29 Sat 18:18 UTC · link
No, your cable modem would be 1.08 terabytes per day.

Does it stop making sense when your calculations for the Roman telescope indicate slower speeds than your connection, which you say is 1/5th the speed?

Now, since the Roman telescope will be at an L2 point, signal acquisition will always be subject to the Earth's rotation. So there will be multiple ground stations involved across the globe.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Deep_Space_Network

If the quoted rate by NASA of 1.5 terabytes per day is accurate, then it will not be downlinking 24/7, but in bursts. 500Mbps is also the max, where the actual range will be 250-500. We'll need to account for RFI and packet loss, etc.